Using a three-headed running back is like using a closer by committee in baseball…..it’s just doesn’t work. The Cowboys need to decide on building the offense around one of the three guys that finished last season on the roster, or they need to draft a RB or sign a free agent that can handle most of the load. 23-year old Felix Jones is Jerry Jones’ boy because they both went to Arkansas. He has the highest upside of any back on the roster but he gets dinged up a lot. Jones played in 16 games for the Cowboys last year and he carried the ball 185 times for 800 yards (4.3 ypc) with 1 TD run. Jones also caught 48 passes for 450 yards (9.4 avg) with 1 TD grab as he does have a nice set of hands to go with his game breaking speed. Jones has now played in 36 games in his first three years with the Cowboys and he has carried the ball 331 times for 1,751 yards (5.3 ypc) with 7 TD runs. He has also caught 69 passes for 579 yards (8.4 avg) with 1 TD grab. Jones has the highest upside of the backs on the roster, but can he handle the pounding of a full workload? I’m not so sure about that.
27-year old Marion Barber looked punch drunk last season from the pounding he has taken in his first six years in the NFL. Barber played in 13 games for the Cowboys last year in which he carried the ball 113 times for 374 yards (3.3 ypc) with 4 TD carries. He also caught 11 passes for 49 yards (4.5 avg) last year. Barber has now played in 88 games in his first six years with the Cowboys and he has carried the ball 1,042 times for 4,358 yards (4.2 ypc) with 47 TD runs. He also has caught 174 passes for 1,280 yards (7.4 avg) with 6 TD grabs with the Cowboys. I have a feeling that his time is coming near an end for the Cowboys.
26-year old Tashard Choice might be the best overall back on the Cowboys but he hasn’t gotten much of a chance to prove it. Choice played in 16 games for the Cowboys last year and he carried the ball 66 times for 243 yards (3.7 ypc) with 3 TD runs and he has also caught 17 passes for 109 yards (6.4 avg). Choice has played in 48 games in his first three years with the Cowboys and he has carried the ball 222 times for 1,064 yards (4.8 ypc) with 8 TD carries. He also has caught 53 passes for 426 yards (8.0 avg) in his first three years with the Cowboys. He needs to have a bigger role with the Cowboys in 2011.